Monday, April 30, 2012

A TRANSCENDENT GOD, FREEWILL, INCARNATION, MIRACLES: Fitting Them All Together


Shortly after I started full-time teaching, a colleague sent me a hurried email, seeking my help in answering an A-level (pre-university exam) student's questions on the interaction between various Christian doctrines about God, cosmology and free will.
I present here a slightly tidied-up version of his email, together with my response.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

THE EMAIL

As part of a lesson, we were discussing an issue that I thought you might be able to input into. The basic question is this:


It has been suggested that the problem of evil (both natural and moral) can in some way be explained by freedom.  [This points to a kind of] God [who] lets the universe unfold, a God who allows humans to evolve in freedom.  Roughly speaking [this equates to] the free will argument. The God in this instance appears to be apart from the universe - not interfering.
 
We then came to the question of miracles.  Now it can be argued that the miracles in the Bible are mythological, recorded for reasons known best to the writers.  If however they are not,then what does this say about the God who allows people to be free?  In other words, is this not a case of an interfering God who impinges himself upon an unsuspecting people?  Is this not inconsistent therefore with the God of the free will argument? In fact isn't the very 'miracle' of Christ the prime example of a God who does interfere in the world in the most definite way?  And again if this is so then how can this be consistent with a God who is apart?

The question hangs upon theodicy and transcendence.  I would appreciate your views, as a practicing Christian,  on a subject that I might relay your reply to [a student] who has been struggling with this one.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


THE RESPONSE

What follows is a purely personal answer, and one which needs to be taken a step at a time. I have tried to use inclusive language but I always think of God as a He – this does not necessarily imply a lack of female attributes. It is going to be quite long, and possibly boring, if all the questions raised are going to be tackled honestly. I will rely on you to extract the level of detail that might be helpful to your student.

The issues are all inter-related, but I will try to isolate them one step at a time.

Step 1: FREE WILL

"It has been suggested that the problem of evil (both natural and moral) can in some way be explained by freedom.  A God who lets the universe unfold, A God who allows humans to evolve (possibly) in freedom.  Roughly speaking the free will argument."

As a Christian believer, I fully endorse the idea that moral evil is the consequence (but not the inevitable consequence) of human freewill. My son has a humanoid toy called Robo-Sapiens that can be programmed to do exactly what its owner wants but which has no free will to make its own choices. Free will logically has to allow the possibility of bad choices which in turn will have bad consequences, but the only alternative would be for us to be robots.

Some philosophers have said that this makes God the author of evil. In common with (presumably) all Christians, I believe that the moral responsibility for evil rests with humans, who universally abuse their gift of free will. We believe this because we do not believe that our God-given freewill logically has to result in bad choices. Indeed, we look to the example of Jesus, who we do not believe ever did wrong despite facing all the temptations we face as ordinary people.

The human abuse of free will for selfish purposes is the cause of all moral evil, but it unquestionably results in a great deal of the natural evil in the world. For example, a flash flood can occur naturally, but climate change resulting from pollution can increase the frequency of such disasters, while selfish land speculation (e.g. selling a dry river bed for poor people to build houses on) can vastly increase the suffering when flash flooding occurs.

Even so, there is natural evil that does not seem to result from any human choices, e.g. earthquakes. Many Christians look to the story of the Fall to explain this (Genesis 3). You do not have to take the story of Adam and Eve literally to observe that sin (abuse of freewill) has a three-fold consequence:  firstly alienation between people and God, secondly alienation between humans and their environment, and thirdly alienation between individual people. (Some commentators would add alienation between the parts of the individual – body, mind, soul). Within this framework, many Christians interpret natural disasters, broken relationships and health breakdowns as symptoms of this alienation. You could call it God’s judgement for this era of human history: handing people over to the consequences of their choices like a stern Deputy Head Teacher, but with the ultimate objective of reconciliation.

Step 2: TRANSCENDENT OR IMMANENT?
"The God in this instance appears to be apart from the universe.  Not interfering."  
  • At one extreme you have the god of the Deist movement: setting the universe in motion and then moving on to somewhere else. Some modern Christians hold a similar view to this, but they are far from historical orthodoxy. 
  • A more moderate position is that taken by Karl Barth: God is the Wholly-Other; concerned with the salvation of individual souls, but utterly transcendent (above and beyond the created order, and beyond direct human experience).
  •  At the opposite extreme, pantheists believe that God IS the universe: that God inhabits every atom and gives reality; that God is limited by the sun total of human experience; perhaps even that God is growing up with the universe (process theology).

This preamble was necessary background to the explanation that orthodox Christianity holds a distinctive position that has been called panentheism: God has a presence in the universe, constantly sustaining it from millisecond to millisecond, and yet maintaining (his) distinct divine essence. In other words, like oil in water, the divine nature does not become confused with created things – it is always recognizable, separate, and in some sense greater. (Many have argued from this that what we call natural laws are no more than observations of the way God most commonly works: If he performs a miracle, he does not interfere with some kind of laws that have a separate existence of their own; he merely chooses for once to work in a different way from the one we are used to. However, I am not going to rely on this argument here).

Thus from my viewpoint as a Christian, you are creating a false dichotomy in saying (as you appear to be) that the granting of free will to humans necessarily implies a God apart from the universe. Which brings us onto the next issue.

Step 3: INCARNATION

"In fact isn't the very 'miracle' of Christ the prime example of a God who does interfere in the world in the most definite way?  And again if this is so then how can this be consistent with a God who is apart?"

The thing that distinguishes Christianity from the other monotheistic religions (but not, curiously enough, from Hinduism) is the assertion that God has dared to defy Plato by breaking through into human history. I interpret this on two quite distinct levels:

 In common with most Christians, I have been drawn into what has been scorned by some thinkers as the “scandal of particularity” – the belief that there is something qualitatively unique about the historical person of Jesus of Nazareth. In other words, I for one accept that the God who is in one sense universal - transcending all times, places and human cultures – chose to “interfere” in human history in one specific time, place and culture.

Far more significantly, for many Christians, the birth of Jesus (and even more his death) are symbols of what I referred to above as panentheism – the belief that God is in the world, not just as a vague “ground of our being” or a may-the-force-be-with-you kind of energy-field, but as a distinct and sentient being who lives, experiences, suffers and ultimately finds transcending joy and peace alongside of and within human life and experience.

Either way, most Christians would say that the prototype for all or any “interference” by God was at the moment of creation – even if you restrict God’s role to simply “causing” the Big Bang. Indeed, Catholics would see both creation and the birth of Jesus as kind of informal sacraments – simply different ways in which the invisible presence and power of God are made detectable to fleshy beings like us. In a sense it is the Creation that is the real archetypal moment of God breaking into history, as (whether or not they believe in a god) most astrophysicists agree that time and space themselves are no more than by-products of that moment of creation. The incarnation is simply phase 2 of creation – a point of transition at which God injects not just his essence but some aspect of his personal consciousness into his handiwork.

Step 4: THE MIRACLES OF JESUS
"We then came to the question of miracles.  Now it can be argued that the miracles in the Bible are mythological, recorded for reasons known best to the writers.  If however they are not then what does this say about the God who allows people to be free.  In other words is this not a case of an interfering God who inpinges himself upon an unsuspecting people.  Is this not inconsistent therefore with the God of the free will argument."

I prefer “symbolic” to “mythological”, since the latter word nowadays carries a clear undertone of falsehood which it did not carry when it was first coined as part of the infant science of literary criticism.

Scholars have spent nearly 2,000 years arguing over the extent to which Jesus knew he was God or had God’s power in his hands. Whether or not his miracles literally happened is just a part (and actually only quite a minor part) of this argument. Even in their biblical context, Jesus’ miracles are quite clearly used as a literary device to convey a theological point.

I personally like the theory of kenosis (Greek for “emptying”) which says that the aspect of God which assumed flesh in the birth of Jesus chose to empty itself of the divine attributes – glory, majesty, power, etc. This is perfectly mainstream Christology, and it is a strange fit with ideas that he consciously wielded divine power at will.

The purpose of his divine assumption of human flesh, if we cut through the many generations of competing atonement theories, is ultimately that the reverse process should occur – that humanity should assume the divine nature. The curse of Eden is then reversed: the deceitful warning of the serpent (“God knows that if you eat the apple” – symbolic of the rebellious exercise of freewill – “you will become like gods”) is ironically fulfilled, with the consequence that humanity is eternally able to use its freewill wisely and unselfishly to the universal good.

I have been trying to argue from a philosophical viewpoint – in the context of the whole Christian doctrine of God – that the idea of miracle is not incompatible with human free-will. Rather, whether they literally happened or not, Jesus’ miracles are signs or symbols of the Kingdom of God – a new social order in which God’s moral values become intuitive and therefore humans will avoid sinful behaviour while keeping their freewill intact: in a nutshell. the fulfilment of human freewill rather than a contradiction of it. But this leads us on to the question of modern miracles.


Step 5: MODERN MIRACLES – ANSWERS TO PRAYER 

I want to make clear that I am open-minded about whether miraculous answers to prayer occur today. On the one hand, I have seen incidents that make it hard for me not to believe that God sometimes intervenes, and no amount of rational argument is going to shake me out of this. However, one of the very few areas in which arch-conservatives and arch-liberals agree is that we should NOT expect miracles to happen. The reasons are of course very different: Liberals say that miracles simply cannot happen because you cannot suspend the laws of nature. In contrast, many conservatives say that the miracles surrounding the life of Jesus were unique events associated with that crucial, mysterious time in history when God was physically on earth, and that their importance to us lies in their symbolism and what they teach – they are not meant to be role-models for our own religious experience. 

 In consequence, the most helpful idea of a miracle I have found is that it is a direct subjective experience of God being present and working in a situation. This leaves the way open to accept that the precise outcome (healing, rescue, inner strength, reconciliation, etc.) may be part of a totally rational chain of cause-and-effect, without denying that the lives and values of witnesses may have been transformed in the process.

A real-life example that I have heard told first hand: A drug-addict goes into a clinic to undergo “cold turkey”, and is braced for a harrowing experience. He prays with a Christian nurse for God’s help. The next day he has broken his addiction without going through any of the convulsions, fever, etc., normally expected. This experience results in a conversion experience. He in turn becomes a Christian worker, liberated, employed in telling his story and helping other addicts. Is this a miracle? I would say yes, despite the fact that his easy exit from the drug could have had purely physiological or psychological causes. The miracle lies more in the interpretation he places on his experience, and the way his life is transformed.

This approach to miracles has a sound biblical basis. One biblical account is that Jesus could do no major miracles in one particular town because the crowd was so sceptical. Unless we believe that the presence of sceptics was enough to block divine powers, we have to believe that the problem there was a psycho-social one: they refused to allow the things they saw to transform their attitudes to life. In another place it says that Jesus refused to do any miracles because all the people had turned out to see was a five-minute sensation – a similar conclusion can be drawn.

If this is spiritually open but (I believe) intellectually honest understanding of miracles is accepted, it would answer a lot of the moral questions associated with the whole issue of prayer:

(a) It does not involve interference with the “laws” of nature.
(b) It does not involve unfair favouritism to “God-botherers”
(e.g. “I know those dozens of farms around here desperately need rain, but I’m going to make it stay dry because the church has prayed for a nice sunny day for the vicarage garden party.)
(c) It does not rule out the possibility of God doing something precious in people’s lives.
(d) It does not imply the need for possibly selfish choices
(e.g. “I ought to be praying for peace in Darfur, but I’ve only got five minutes to spare and I need to spend that time praying that I pass my driving test tomorrow). 


In fact, it suggests that prayer is not a means of getting God to do what we want. Rather, it is a means of making ourselves available to God, to do what God wants. In other words, what is changed in prayer is not God’s will, but our human wills and perceptions. In still other words, the process is not us changing the world by pestering God, but God changing the world by graciously allowing us to collaborate with (him).

I know a married couple in their twenties who spent nearly three years in Darfur, living in indescribable squalor and unbelievable physical danger, working for a Christian disaster-relief organisation. This happened because they spent several months praying to God to do something about the humanitarian crisis there.


“In other words is this not a case of an interfering God who inpinges himself upon an unsuspecting people?”
Perhaps in one sense you could say that.

“Is this not inconsistent therefore with the God of the free will argument?
 I think it is the fulfilment of what humans were given  freewill for.

Don’t get me wrong: I am well aware that many religious people (Christian or otherwise) have quite self-centred and tribal understandings of who God is and what they can expect God to do for them. Ultimately, they will have to take moral responsibility for that. However, it is my personal belief that this is a stage of spiritual adolescence (sorry if that sounds condescending) that people go through, and that they are better placed for future spiritual growth by having a God they believe is powerful enough to be worth praying to than are those who rule out the possibility of real spiritual experience.

Saturday, October 8, 2011

THE BALLAD OF FINRAEL


Written during a quiet spell at the office (1984)

THE BALLAD OF FINRAEL
   
The Sun sank slowly in the West
As Elven warriors reached the crest,
And, looking down the valley steep,
The saw the town sink into sleep.

They waited fast till silence reigned,
Then made their way down leafy lanes
Until they reached the village square
Wherein they gathered, fierce and fair.

They waited noiseless till  the dawn,
Their weapons sheathed, their ranks close-drawn.
But as the cock crowed break of day
They stole an orphan child away,
For in the land of Elvenhome
Beneath the heavens’ starry dome,
Where is no death and time runs slow,
Where crystal streams through meadows flow
While Elven voices sweetly sing,
A mortal may alone be King.

They wrapped the child in robes of green
And slipped away, by no man seen,
For though the turf was soft, and wet
From dewdrops that were forming yet,
They left no footprints in the ground
That might by sharp-eyed men be found.

They travelled far,  by eyes unseen,
Concealed by cloaks of dappled green.
With joy their ageless faces shone
Fair to eclipse the wintry sun.
Their laughter sweet and voices clear
Could scarce be heard by human ear
But as the singing of the birds,
So pure their thoughts and true their words.

They marched for days through copse and grove,
And reached at last a rocky cove
Too steep for mortals to assay,
Wherein a barque at anchor lay
Whose ivory hull did seem to fly,
Her cedar masts to touch the sky.

For many a month the vessel sailed
Towards the West, and through the veil
That separates from mortal ken
Those Lands forever close to men
(Save for the One by Starlight bless’d
Who, passing every moral test,
Shall live beneath the starry dome
And rule the land of Elvenhome).

As cold Arcturus watched benign,
The barque traversed the Borderline
And, leaving stormy seas behind
Sailed on, through Faerie oceans kind
Beneath the myriad shining stars,
Where nothing joy and sweetness mars.
And though the barque did swiftly go,
No earthly wind was felt to blow,
For love of Home propelled the Craft
Which sped on like a feathered shaft.

As weariness began to bite
The shoreline came at last in sight,
And, with one welling, liquid voice,
The Elven crew at last rejoiced
To see the Land they loved so well
Draw near across the gentle swell.
But all too soon each voice was hushed
And every heart with ice was touched.

No voice across the water hailed,
And in the darkness something wailed.
A deathly cold consumed the crew,
And in his heart each sailor knew
That while they journey’s oversea,
Some evil fate had come to be.

They walked the streets in blackest gloom,
As thunderclouds above them loomed
And blotted out the starry sky
Where Elvish thoughts do always fly.

At length they reached the palace square
And saw a black flag flying there
With words of fire that did proclaim:
“NEKROS IS KING – LET CHAOS REIGN”.

At once, a band of brutish guards
Came as from nowhere, waving swords.
The Elves, retreating, fiercely fought,
But freedom at a price was bought:
Outnumbered by their hated foes,
Nine warriors fell, and never rose.
Nekros the warlock, grim and foul,
Enshrouded in his night-black cowl,
Had found his way into the Tower
And carried off the Orb of Power
That Elvenhome at peace had kept
While all the powers of darkness slept.
Despair and death now walked abroad
As servants of the Warlock Lord.

Between the mountains and the plain,
Vast forests had for aeons lain
Where roaring falls and dappled glades
Were home to Elfdom’s earthbound shades.
There, in communion with the trees,
Lived great wild beasts in careless ease,
And there the Elven dispossessed
Rebuilt a homeland in the West.

Beyond the gaze of Warlock grim
They never ceased to harry him,
And roving bands of Elvish troops
Would strike at dawn in lightning swoops,
To ambush Nekros’ hapless men
And fade into the night again.
Thus many Black Dragoons were lost,
But Nekros did not count the cost.

In course of time, in Elvish guise,
The mortal prince grew strong and wise.
He took the name of Finrael,
And, under Elfdom’s magic spell,
Assumed the Crown as Elvenking
And wore with pride the Royal Ring.
The Warlock Lord slept deep and well,
And nothing knew of Finrael.

The sands of time flowed ever on,
And Finrael desired a son.
He searched forest kingdom wide
For one to be his queen and bride,
And found a maid called Selenai
Who won his heart and pleased his eye.

Malivar was an Elven knight,
A warrior bold who loved to fight.
He many times as time went by
Had tried to woo fair Selenai.
Now, under envy’s bitter spell,
He swore revenge on Finrael.

One day, upon an urgent Quest,
Two warriors rode into the West.
For many days they travelled far,
The King, and jealous Malivar.

Unto the Caves of Ice they came,
Where lived a beast of evil name,
A dragon with a massive horde
Of treasure, and a magic sword.
Her fangs were spears, her talons knives
With which she’s taken countless lives.
Her breath was like the Primal Flame,
And Slark the Mindworm was her name.

She only had one certain bane:
The Sword that in her caves had lain
Since Ceduil, a warrior bold,
Had perished in the caverns cold;
A sword of great renown in lore
That few had dared to wield in war;
A sword just known as Dragonbane
That many fearsome worms had slain.

The King and his unfaithful squire
Would not confront the dragon’s fire,
But of a secret entrance knew
Well hidden from the monster’s view,
Where, with a rope and iron nerves,
A man might enter unobserved.

The fearless King went in the lead,
And climbing from his rowan steed
Made fast his rope to an outcrop,
And into darkness bravely dropped.

Now Malivar, his eyes of jade,
Drew swift a silvered hunting blade,
And stooping low his work to do,
He cut his Master’s lifeline through.
Then, with a laugh both grim and gay,
He took both steeds and rode away.

Finrael in the frozen dark
Smelled the foul stench of Mindworm Slark,
And, falling to the icy floor,
He hit his head and knew no more.

“Alas! How come you home alone?
Whither is my husband gone?”

“Like Ceduil , he paid the price,
And lies within the Caves of Ice;
A victim of the Dragon’s ire,
Consumed by that undying fire.”

“I ever knew that by and by
My mortal King must one day die.
And yet I loved him more than life.
Alas for me, immortal wife.”

Marooned beneath the permafrost
Walked Finrael in the darkness lost.
Stout-hearted still, he felt no fear,
But tears of rage were ever near,
And burning like a shooting star
He cursed the name of Malivar.

As thirst and hunger took their toll,
A mad euphoria gripped his soul.
He laughed at visions fell and stark
That danced before him in the dark
To mock his noble scorn of death
Beneath the Dragon’s fiery breath.

At last a gleam of light he saw,
A moment’s glimpse and then no more;
Perhaps hallucination yet,
But off toward the light he set,
Till came he to a chamber round
In which a glowing egg he found.

Then, as in wonderment he watched
The baby dragon slowly hatched,
And though its countenance was fell
It won the heart of Finrael.

Its paper wings were frail and weak,
Its eyes unblinking, soft and meek,
And when he knelt the chick to hold,
He found its skin was dry and cold.
Without its mother’s warming fire,
The tiny life would soon expire.

Careless of life, forgetting Quest,
He hugged the creature to his breast,
And though it seared him near to death
He shared with it his anguished breath,
And caring not for all his pains,
He fed it blood from his own veins.
Then, as oblivion drew near,
Great Slark the Mindworm did appear,
Looked deep into his dying mind,
And there the gift of life did find.

From fire she wove a cradle warm
To keep her offspring safe from harm,
Then cast a spell of painless sleep
And flew into the caverns deep
With Finrael the Elvenking
Fast cradled neath her beating wing.

For many days the deeps she flew
In utter dark the caverns through,
Until her weary wings she furled
At the bright centre of the world,
Where at the planet’s very core
Unceasing springs of healing pour,
And, casting him into the streams,
She woke him from his spellbound dreams:
A man no more, for none can fade
Who in the Streams of Life have bathed.

“Brave Elvenking, my debt is paid.
Your broken frame is now remade,
And better than it was before;
New vigour you now have in store.”

“Great Dragon, in your Kind I see
A wisdom that was veiled to me.
I see your heart is pure and strong,
Your knowledge great, your memory long.
Yet in our chronicles I read
Of dragons’ cruelty and greed.”

“Your Elvish race is old and wise,
Your beauty fair delights the eyes,
Yet since before your people’s birth
We Dragonfolk have ruled the Earth.
We long have loved you, Men and Elves,
Yet ever must defend ourselves,
For ever must you fighting go
In fear of that you do not know.
And many of my Kind have died
As victims of your Elvish pride.
You owe it to our patient grace
That we have not destroyed your race,
For it is quite within our power
To wipe you out inside an hour.”

“Then hear my words, my new-found friend,
The Dragonquest is at an end.
No man shall Elf or Man conspire
To quench a Dragon’s primal fire.”

So homeward came the Elvenking,
Borne fast beneath the Dragon’s wing.
The magic sword clutched to his chest,
No longer doomed for Dragonquest,
Was now as Dragonfriend renamed
And as a tool of justice famed.

Proud Malivar, to exile banned,
Was soon to die by his own hand,
While Finrael, a man no more,
Was to his loving wife restored.

Next day, a distant cloud was seen,
All swaithed in fire but coloured green.
It closer sped and filled the sky:
A thousand dragons flying by.
Swift on to Elvenport they flew,
And came into the Warlock’s view.
His towers crumbled, soldiers fled,
But in a minute all were dead,
And Nekros in his armoured room
Was soon by primal fire consumed.
Then, as the palace fiercely burned,
The Elves unto their homes returned.
The Dragons flew into the West,
Their power unveiled, the Elves impressed.

Brave Finrael, immortal grown,
Had to give up the Elvish throne,
But in the Forestlands was Lord
And Guardian of the Magic Sword,
Forever to be famed in lore
As Ender of the Dragon War.

And soon an Elven vessel sailed
Into the East, towards the veil
That separates from mortal ken
The Lands forever closed to Men
(Save One who by the Stars is blessed
And passing every moral test
Shall Westward pass across the foam
To be crowned King of Elvenhome.

It sailed into a rocky bay
Too steep for mortals to assay,
And, troubled not by ocean’s roar,
The Elven warriors stepped ashore.

They hunted East and hunted West
To find the child the Stars had blessed,
Till, coming to a highland bleak
They felt the presence they did seek.
 
The Sun was sinking in the West
As Elven warriors reached the crest,
And, looking down the valley steep,
They watched the town sink into sleep.

They waited fast till silence reigned,
Then made their way down leafy lanes
Until they reached the village square
Wherein they gathered, fierce and fair.

They waited noiseless till  the dawn,
Their weapons sheathed, their ranks close-drawn.
Then, as the cock crowed break of day,
They stole an orphan child away,
For in the land of Elvenhome
Beneath the heavens’ starry dome,
Where is no death and time runs slow,
Where crystal streams through meadows flow
While Elven voices sweetly sing,
A mortal may alone be King.

Sunday, May 8, 2011

WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES CHRIST MAKE? EVALUATING DIFFERENT THEOLOGICAL MODELS OF THE ATONEMENT


What Difference Does Christ Make? 
Evaluating different theological models
of the Atonement.
John Bailey


Introduction: The Penal Substitutionary Model

A prolific American preacher and peace activist begins his widely read on-line essay on the meaning of the atonement with these words:

“The foundational truth of Christianity is that Christ Jesus died on the cross for our sins (1 Cor 15:3). In this way he fulfilled the old covenant sacrificial system, reconciled us to God, and changed our lives forever. That is the doctrine of the Atonement. Its reality is not in dispute. However, many Christians struggle to understand and live this doctrine better. We know that the Atonement works; but how it works is not as clear.”   (Mattison)

In stating that Christ died “for” our sins in fulfilment of the Hebrew sacrificial system, but professing agnosticism as to the precise mechanics, the author presents a picture of the atonement that most Christians would accept. Many would go further, however, and insist on explicating the phrase “died for our sins” to mean “died in our place to suffer the divine punishment for our sins”. This more specific doctrine, known as penal substitution, is not univocally supported by the New Testament but has much to recommend it:

·      It can be argued strongly from Scripture (e.g. Ro 3:25);
·      It harmonises God’s perfect love and perfect justice;
·      It is ruthlessly honest as to the nature and cause of humanity’s predicament;
·      It makes sense of the absolute necessity of Christ’s death;
·      It tends to inspire vigorous personal and corporate evangelism.

However, it is impossible to ignore the testimony of the many Christians who have reservations about forensic and sacrificial atonement theories. Quite apart from those (e.g. J. D. Crossan) who see Christianity as divorced from the Jesus events, there are many to whom “the language of sacrifice...is either empty because it is unintelligible, or offensive because it is morally primitive.” (Heim, 2001). It is by no means certain, moreover, that forensic atonement honours the spirit of the sacrificial system depicted in the Hebrew Scriptures in quite the way its proponents claim. The Catholic historian Lawrence Boadt writes:

“Sacrifices were well known throughout the ancient world, but in Israel, unlike in some Canaanite cults, the sacrifice was never considered a magical ritual that brought God to act in a certain way. The spirit of adoration and silence and the obedience of the people before Yahweh always stand out. And when the prophets do condemn abuses of sacrifice, they almost always attack that slipping over into a conviction that God must accept this gift and then do what is requested.” (Boadt, 1984, pp.272-3)

The New Testament did not invent vicarious suffering and death,[1] but as Boadt describes the five sacrifices decreed in Leviticus 1-7 (viz. Holocausts, Grain Offerings, Peace Offerings, Sin Offerings, Guilt Offerings), it is evident that the forensic interpretation of the Cross is not a perfect conceptual match for any of them.

My conclusion is that theological models function like parables; however much they have to tell us, their analogies can only be pushed so far. Indeed, different models act as a check on one another, and I am confident that many of the alternatives put forward in good faith over the centuries can provide complementary insights into the richness of God’s saving grace.

I will be using as an organising framework for this review of some alternative models one of the key Reformed texts of modern times, Louis Berkhof’s Systematic Theology (Berkhof, 1958, pp384-391). I do so not out of unreserved concurrence with his opinions, but because he marshals all the most important theories and the key arguments against them in chronological order – an approach that often throws light on the dialectical process that produced them. And unlike Berkhof, I will be looking for helpful insights in these diverse models as well as weaknesses.


Types of Atonement Theory

Theories of the atonement cover a broad spectrum of ideas, and have been more influenced by cultural predispositions than their proponents would admit. However, they can generally be mapped in relation to the following axes:

·      Objectivity – humanity’s real situation, including God’s attitude towards us; Christ typically characterised as hero and victim;

·      Subjectivity – humanity’s perceptions of reality and its attitude towards God and others; Christ seen primarily as revelator and teacher.

Most commentators distinguish from these a third set of ideas focusing on humanity’s knowledge or understanding of its situation and potential, in which Christ is seen as reconciler and healer.[2] These ideas are present in most theories, however, and the key distinction is whether God’s or man’s attitudes are seen as paramount.


The Ransom Theory

The Ransom model belongs in the first category, the family of objective theories in which Christ is characterised as the conquering hero or sacrificial victim who brings about a difference in humanity’s situation. First proposed by Irenaeus of Lyons in the 2nd century C.E., it was predicated on the rather dualistic belief[3] that human sin had given Satan legitimate rights over humanity. Versions of the theory differ as to just how Christ’s death annulled these rights[4], but whether by combat, fair payment or trickery God emerged victorious over the powers of darkness.

The scandal of a crucified Messiah and the psychology of a persecuted minority led the early Church Fathers to express these ideas in rather shallow triumphalistic terms,[5] but pictures of Christ as victor over dark forces are clearly biblical (1Co 15:57; Eph 4:8) and as empowering in spiritual warfare today as in their original context.[6] Gustaf Aulén’s influential “Christus Victor” (1930) stressed the authentic note of victory in Irenaeus’ theory over its mythic elements, and this theme of victory in Christ may prove particularly valuable in adapting orthodox Christian soteriology to the needs of growing churches in the Third World where spiritual and socio-economic struggles go hand-in-hand.


The Recapitulation Theory

The Recapitulation Theory, also associated with Irenaeus, held that that Christ recapitulates or replays all the elements of human life inherited from Adam – including those associated with sin. The point of the theory is that the obedience of Christ compensates for Adam’s disobedience and reverses the consequences of the Fall; in the process, he communicates immortality and a real ethical transformation to those who are united to him by faith.

Few atonement theories fit neatly into a single category. Recapitulation is primarily another way for Christ to bring about a difference in the objective human situation, i.e. a cosmos corrupted by the Fall. However, it seems to foreshadow later subjective and mystical theories in which Christ is presented as mediator of a change in humanity itself. In the mystical theory, the divine life is said to have entered the life of humanity in order to lift it to the level of the divine; Christ’s identification with men and women is such that he was able to purify human nature by his life of obedience, and able by his death to eliminate the very principle of depravity that separated humanity from God. It is the resulting progressive transformation in our subconscious nature that really constitutes redemption.

These later mystical theories generally fare better than the original Recapitulation model in explaining the value and necessity of Christ’s death, and why Christians continue to struggle morally. Nevertheless, Irenaeus’ picture of Christ as the second Adam has strong Pauline roots (e.g. Ro 5:12-21) and makes a parallel appeal to the Hebrew scriptures; it evidently helped the early church in its struggles against heresy and persecution, and there is a clear accessibility for both modern and post-modern cultures in its vision of a humanity whose heredity is blessed and cursed with conflicting moral and relational polarities.  


The Satisfaction Theory

There is a reverent and sentimental hopefulness about the atonement theories of the early church that makes them easy to warm to, however short on intellectual rigour they may appear in hindsight. In contrast, the Satisfaction Theory of Anselm, which dates from the late 11th century, is of all models one of the hardest to like.

It was based on a sound realisation that the time-honoured Ransom Theory accorded too much status to Satan, and reasoned that if a ransom was paid at all it must have been payable to God himself. This was the first of the family of formal soteriologies that focus attention on the difference Christ’s death makes to God’s attitude vis-à-vis humanity, and it paved the way for the propitiatory language of the Protestant Reformation over 400 years later.

However, Anselm’s conception of satisfaction differed from Luther’s in at least one crucial respect: it regarded sin as an offence not against God’s perfect justice but against his personal honour. Such an offence needed to be vindicated by either punishment or satisfaction, and since God in his mercy rejected punishment the only possible source of the infinite satisfaction required was the death of his Son. Christ’s obedience was actually no more than his duty as a man, but by suffering and dying in a way he was not obligated to do by any sinfulness of his own, he delivered to God the infinite glory needed to cancel out the dishonour of human sin. In doing so he earned a “supererogatory credit” or reward that could be passed on to those who live according to the commandments of the gospel.

The distinction between this and the later theory of penal substitution may seem pedantic to some, but the differences are actually quite profound. Berkhof manages to sound condescending when he says that the concept of supererogatory credit is rather like the Catholic doctrine of penance applied to the work of Christ, but the parallels with discredited penitential practices are not imaginary. Unwittingly perhaps, Anselm brands God with the same medieval human values of status, honour and morality that underpinned duelling – the spilling of blood for the sake of honour – and the indulgence system that would one day provoke Luther to rebellion.

Anselm deserves credit for working out a God-centred objective picture of the atonement that the Reformers would build on to better effect. However, he neglected the revelatory significance of Christ’s living ministry – an omission the Reformers would rectify through a distinction between Christ’s active and passive obedience –and it is perhaps due to this that he fails to provide a credible basis for the transference of Christ’s supererogatory credit to humanity. Ultimately, his theory tends to undermine a proper sense of gratitude to Christ or moral responsibility for his suffering, and it has sometimes been disparagingly called the Commercial Theory.


The Moral Influence Theory

This foundational model of subjective atonement was advocated by Anselm’s near-contemporary Abelard, possibly in shocked reaction to the former’s suggestion that Christ’s suffering and death gave God some kind of grim satisfaction. Depicting Christ principally as Revealer and Educator, the theory holds that his death was no more or less than a revelation of divine love and solidarity in suffering that softens human hearts and leads to the repentance that brings divine forgiveness. It is firmly rooted in a certain strand of biblical theology (notably Luke/Acts and the prophetic tradition), and has attracted massive support since the Enlightenment – in fact it is probably the principal rival to sacrificialism in orthodox Christianity today.

It has been plausibly objected by Berkhof (p.387) and others that “this theory robs the atonement of its objective character, and thereby ceases to be a real theory of the atonement. It is at most only a one-sided theory of reconciliation.”[7] And whether or not this is accepted, there are other objections to Abelard’s theory:

·      It predated the scholarship that understands biblical theology as dynamic process. The leading evangelical author of the 20th century comments on Peter’s Pentecost sermon in Acts ch.2, one of the key supporting texts for this theory, “No developed doctrine of the Atonement is yet expressed” (Stott, 1990, p.75);
·      It ignores the sheer weight of sacrificial language in the New Testament, along with the many pointers to God’s justice and wrath (e.g. Romans ch. 1), and thereby risks making repentance and divine forgiveness cheap;
·      It does not really explain the need for Christ’s death, and is thus held by many to introduced a note of arbitrary cruelty into God’s supposed love.[8]
·      It does not explain how salvation reaches those who lived before the Incarnation, children, or others who are incapable of apprehending or responding to Christ’s moral influence.

As a complement to objective models, however, this theory has much to teach us about the role in salvation of human repentance and God’s forgiving heart – themes whose centrality to a proper understanding of the Hebrew sacrificial system has all too often been overlooked (Morris, 1988). Moreover, this theory need not be presented in a way that detracts from the uniqueness of salvation in Christ, and it inhabits a universal episteme that erects few barriers to transculturation. Above all it provides solid theological foundations for a Christianity that is engaged with the practical needs of the world – it is no coincidence that social reformers and campaigners for peace and justice are often deeply committed to Abelard’s picture of the atonement.


The Example Theory

Abelard’s ideas were developed in a more radical direction by the Socinians in the 16th century, in reaction to the penal substitution theory of the Protestant Reformers. This version of subjective atonement is based on a sweeping assumption that there is no principle of retributive justice in God that insists on the punishment of sin. In consequence, said Fausto Sozzini (Socinius), salvation is achievable through humanity’s own God-given moral faculties.

The Socinian theory is based on the lowest of all Christologies; Christ is not understood as divine in any meaningful sense, there is no direct connection between his death and human salvation, and in revealing the way of individual faith and obedience he is scarcely even unique.[9] Berkhof sees this as a “revival and concoction” of several ancient heresies: a Pelagian denial of human depravity, an adoptionist Christology, a Scotist attribution of arbitrariness to God’s will, and a retrograde appeal to the Anselmian ideas that he deems the Reformation to have rendered obsolete.

Berkhof is generally too sweeping in his rejection of alternatives to Reformed orthodoxy, but the crux of the matter here, as he succinctly puts it on p.388, is that “Christ is our Redeemer before He can be our example.” The Christian certainly is called to follow Christ’s example, but imitation alone is an inadequate response to God’s self-revelation.[10] Abelard’s theory is friendly to this principle as its fundamental dynamic is one of heartbreak, repentance and forgiveness. In contrast the Socinian model is an arrogant and divisive construct; it clashes directly with objective atonement theories and thus does nothing to enrich our understanding of God’s grace.


The Governmental Theory

The Governmental Theory, which still has a considerable following in Arminian and Wesleyan circles, was put forward by Huig de Groot (Grotius) in the early 17th century in an attempt to mediate between Reformed and Socinian positions. It creates  as many problems as it solves, however. At its heart lies an assumption that the Law is a creation of God’s arbitrary will rather than an expression of his essential character and being. On this most fragile of pretexts, it is argued that God’s justice does not demand that all the Law’s requirements be met. The sinner theoretically deserves death, but God chooses to set the penalty aside for believers. In the final analysis Christ did not die in man’s place to secure forgiveness, but to demonstrate the inviolability of God’s law and so uphold his moral government.

Perhaps we see in this theory an echo of the concurrent struggle of Europe’s nation states to consolidate their own governmental authority. Either way it is fatally compromised on logical as well as theological grounds; it is superficially objective in its focus on God’s sovereignty and Christ’s sacrifice, but it attributes no substantive benefit for humankind by Christ’s life or death since it sees our forgiveness as the result of the Father’s arbitrary will to forgive. There is thus little purpose to Christ’s death beyond demonstrating the inviolability of a Law which God’s own actions have shown to be violable. The one practical value of Christ’s death in this scenario might have been as a deterrent to future infractions of the Law – had not God already shown his willingness to set the penalty aside. Most offensive of all is the suggestion that God might be existentially disintegrated, his essence and his actions mutually at odds. Indeed I am little more sure than with the Example theory that this model is truly Trinitarian.


Conclusions

I have barely scratched the surface, but I have attempted to show by a few case studies how we can enrich our understanding of Christ’s work through a humble but critical consideration of different theological models. I would like to finish by demonstrating with the aid of quotations from three credible theologians that this approach is neither arbitrary nor vague.

Dr. Tom Wright, a highly respected Anglican theologian and former Bishop of Durham, describes the Cross in one characteristic passage as

“the moment when the evil and pain of all the world were heaped up into one place, there to be dealt with once and for all… 
“Jesus’ final great act of love draws to a climax all those actions throughout his ministry…in which we see the deeply human…and characteristically God-filled Jesus truly at work.”  (Wright, 2000, p.68)

If Wright does not feel a need to identify the precise mechanism by which this great act of love deals with the world’s evil and pain, Dr. Michael Ramsey, another leading Anglican thinker of the 20th century, sees not the human theological construct of atonement but rather the God-given signs of Death and Resurrection as the events that characterise the nature of Christianity. He continues,

“It is a gospel of life through death, of losing life so as to find it . . . the Christian’s act of allegiance to the risen Lord Jesus was, and still is, an act of acceptance of the way of the Cross.” (Ramsey, 1985, p.31).

And finally the influential Catholic liturgist James Empereur, SJ, stresses the importance of reserve in using theological models:

“Tolerance of pluralism is the only solution. No benefit will result from trying to impose any one model as the last word . . . [The theologian] is called to go beyond these images. He/she must use the image in a reflective and critical way . . . The use of models in theology should emphasise for us that at no time do our concepts and symbols actually capture the infinite that lies behind our liturgical experiences. And since all models have their limitations, the task is to work with several models as complementary.”  (Empereur, 1987, p.66)


I continue to believe that Christ died in my place for my sins, and I find in forensic theories the most complete and satisfying explanation of his work. However, some of the alternative frameworks I have outlined help to open up the extraordinary richness in God’s mercy in a way that no one intellectual construct ever could.

In consequence, and in spite of Stott’s persuasive argument for “an understanding of [the atonement] which reclaims from misrepresentation the great biblical concepts of ‘substitution’, ‘satisfaction’ and ‘propitiation’” (Stott, 1986, p.10), I find the term “participation” as used by Mattison in some ways more illuminating; it integrates more smoothly with non-sacrificial language, and above all it emphasises our calling to go to the cross with Christ rather than merely letting him occupy it for us. It is in these terms that I can most clearly see Christ’s blood as the seal on a new covenant between God and man, and preach to myself and others an active sacrificial concern for the needs of a suffering world.



BIBLIOGRAPHY

AULÉN, G. (1969) Christus Victor: An Historical Study of the Three Main Types of the Idea of the Atonement New York, Macmillan.

BELLINGER, C. (2001) Bibliography on the Doctrine of the Atonement [on-line] Available: http://www.gospelcom.net/regent/regentnew/library/Biblio_atonement.html

BERKHOF, L. (1958) Systematic Theology Edinburgh, Banner of Truth Trust.

BOADT, L. (1984) Reading the Old Testament: An Introduction New York, Paulist Press.

­EHRMAN, B. D. (2000) The New Testament: A Historical Introduction to the Early Christian Writings New York, Oxford University Press.

EMPEREUR, J. (1987) Worship: Exploring the Sacred Washington D.C., The Pastoral Press.

HEIM, S. M. (2001) “Why Does Jesus’ Death Matter?” in The Christian Century 7 March 2001, pp.12-17 [online] Available: http://www.religion-online.org/cgi-bin/relsearchd.dll/showarticle?item_id=2138

KÜNG, H. (1993) Credo: The Apostles’ Creed Explained for Today London, SCM Press.

MATTISON, M. M. (undated) “The Meaning of the Atonement” in The Open House Church Articles [online] Available: http://www.auburn.edu/~allenkc/openhse/atonement.html

MCGRATH, A. E. (1998) Historical Theology: An Introduction to the History of Christian Thought Oxford, Blackwell Publishing.

MCGRATH, A. E., Ed. (2001a) The Christian Theology Reader, 2nd Ed. Oxford, Blackwell Publishing.

MCGRATH, A. E. (2001b) Christian Theology: An Introduction, 3rd Ed. Oxford, Blackwell Publishing.

MORRIS, L. L. (1988) “Atonement” in Ferguson, S. B. and Wright, D. F., Ed. New Dictionary of Theology Leicester, Inter-Varsity Press.

RAMSEY, M. (1985) The Christian Priest Today London, SPCK

SCHAFF, P. (undated) “The New Schaff-Herzog Encyclopaedia of Religious Knowledge” in Christian Classics Ethereal Library [online] Available: http://www.ccel.org/s/schaff/encyc/encyc02/htm/iv.vi.lxv.htm

SIDER, R. J. (1993) Good News and Good Works: A Theology for the Whole Gospel Grand Rapids, MI; Baker Books.

STOTT, J. R. W. (1986) The Cross of Christ Leicester, Inter-Varsity Press.

STOTT, J. R. W. (1990) The Message of Acts Leicester, Inter-Varsity Press.
           
UNDERHILL, E. (1944) Light of Christ London, Longmans.
  
WRIGHT, N. T. (1996) Jesus and the Victory of God (Christian Origins and the Question of God vol. 2) London, SPCK.

WRIGHT, N. T. (2000) The Challenge of Jesus London, SPCK.



[1] The idea was common to both Jewish and Greek thought; it occurs more than once in the deutero-canonical writings and is the central device in Euripides’ drama Alcestis of around 438 B.C.E. (Ehrman, 2000, p.257).
[2] The English mystic Evelyn Underhill, for example, refers to Christ the Teacher, Christ the Healer and Christ the Rescuer (Underhill, 1944).
[3] Perhaps resulting from an over-literal reading of Mk 10:45, which states that Christ died “to give his life as a ransom for many”.
[4] Gregory the Great, for example, saw Christ’s humanity as bait and his divinity as the hook.
[5] Such was the embarrassment of the crucifixion to much of the early church, it was not until the conversion of Constantine that the cross achieved emblematic status (Küng, 1993, p.65).
[6] Indeed, the theory still attracts considerable popular support. I quote from a recent and widely circulated e-mail chain letter (no attribution available): “And what will you do when you get done with [humanity]?” Jesus asked. “Oh, I’ll kill ‘em,” Satan glared proudly. “How much do you want for them?” Jesus asked . . . Satan looked at Jesus and sneered, “All your tears, and all your blood.” Jesus said, “DONE!” Then He paid the price.
[7] Over against Berkhof, it could be argued that reconciliation is at the heart of the atonement – the term itself is thought to have been coined by Tyndale as a translation of the L. reconciliatio. This counter-argument cannot be pushed too far, however, as reconciliatio itself is not a wholly adequate translation of the Gk. katallage, which in Hellenised Jewish culture carried rich overtones of exchange (Gk. vb. katallasso) as well as the interrelated Hebrew concepts of “covering” (kopher) and ritual atonement (kipper).
[8] As Berkhof states in slightly cumbersome syntax on p.387, “The sufferings and death of Christ were a manifestation of God’s love only, if it was the only way to save sinners.”
[9] Although there is an anomalous and rather Anselmian assumption in the Example Theory that Christ passes on to believers some kind of reward received for his own obedience.
[10] As George Bernard Shaw has Don Juan answer a companion in Hell who is complaining that all her good deeds have been wasted: “No: you were fully and clearly warned. For your bad deeds, vicarious atonement, mercy without justice. For your good deeds, justice without mercy. We have many good people here.” (Man and Superman Act III, s.166)